Casper, WY resident Melissa Benson thinks she has found her perfect match when she meets young and caring LaShawn King. Their romance blossoms, and she falls in love with the new man in her life. As with many relationships, Melissa soon discovers that romance is not always picture perfect. The couple has their difficulties, but just when Melissa thinks everything is back on track, a new nightmare unfolds. New England native Kevin Leland is also searching for romance when he meets Christine Billis on a popular dating site. According to the site, it's a surefire match. The pair form a bond online and decide to meet in person. As their relationship begins to grow, it suddenly takes a turn down a dark path when Christine reveals a troubling secret.